Amanda Pasko holds a Master’s in Nutritional Epidemiology from the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and a Master’s in Nutrition from the UNC Gillings School of Global Public Health. To her, it is rewarding to help others reach…
Intermittent fasting isn’t technically a “diet” in the traditional sense. Unlike many eating plans that restrict specific food groups or require you to count every macronutrient, intermittent fasting focuses on when you eat rather than what you eat.
This eating pattern involves cycling between periods of eating and fasting, a pattern that often reduces calorie consumption by limiting your eating window. The approach has roots in human evolution and religious practices, but modern research has started to uncover its potential metabolic benefits.
Many people achieve remarkable results with intermittent fasting, while others find it doesn’t suit their lifestyle or health needs. The key lies in understanding the various approaches available and selecting one that aligns with your individual circumstances, health goals, and daily routine.
This comprehensive guide will walk you through the different intermittent fasting plans, help you determine which approach might work best for you, and provide practical guidance on implementation.
By the end, you’ll have the knowledge needed to make an informed decision about whether intermittent fasting deserves a place in your wellness journey.
Understanding the various intermittent fasting approaches is crucial for making an informed choice. Each method offers different benefits and challenges, and what works for one person may not suit another.
Time-restricted eating represents the most popular and accessible form of intermittent fasting. This approach involves consuming all your daily calories within a specific window, creating natural fasting periods (1).
The 16:8 method stands as the most common approach, involving 16 hours of fasting, without any calorie intake, followed by an 8-hour eating window (2). Many people find this sustainable as it often means simply skipping one meal, breakfast or dinner. For example, you might eat between 12 pm and 8 pm, then fast until noon the following day.
The 14:10 method offers a gentler introduction, with 14 hours of fasting and a 10-hour eating window. This might involve eating from 9 am to 7 pm (3). The 18:6 method increases the fasting period to 18 hours with a 6-hour eating window, while the more restrictive 20:4 method (sometimes called the Warrior Diet) involves eating within just a 4-hour window.
Complete alternate day fasting involves alternating between full fasting days and normal eating days (4). On fasting days, you consume no energy-containing foods or beverages – only water, black coffee, and plain tea. This approach can be challenging and may lead to health downsides, including poor energy and focus, dizziness, and loss in bone and muscle strength, but may produce rapid results with weight loss.
Modified alternate day fasting offers a more manageable alternative. On fasting days, you consume approximately 20-25% of your normal caloric intake (usually 500-600 calories) (5). In a complete or modified alternate day fasting approach, individuals eat as they choose on their non-fasting days. Modified alternate day fasting forms the basis of popular approaches such as the 5:2 diet.
If you wish to free yourself from all the extra pounds that have been weighing you down for way too long, start using the BetterMe: Health Coaching app and overhaul your entire life!
The 5:2 diet involves eating normally for five days per week and severely restricting calories for two non-consecutive days. On restriction days, women typically consume approximately 500 calories while men consume approximately 600 calories (6). The non-consecutive aspect is important for recovery and adherence.
Extended fasting involves fasting periods lasting 24 hours or longer. The 24-hour fast (also known as Eat-Stop-Eat) might involve fasting from dinner one day until dinner the next day (3). Some practitioners engage in 36-hour, 48-hour, or even longer fasts, although these require careful medical supervision.
Ramadan fasting involves abstaining from food and drink from dawn to sunset, typically lasting approximately 12 hours depending on the season and geographic location. During Ramadan, practitioners usually consume one larger meal after sunset and a lighter meal before dawn (7).
Other religious fasting practices include periodic fasting observed by Latter-day Saints members and the eating patterns of some Seventh-day Adventists who consume their last meal in the afternoon, creating extended nighttime fasting periods (5).
For those interested in implementing any of these approaches with proper meal planning, consider exploring our comprehensive 7-day meal plan for intermittent fasting to get started.
Read more: 12-Hour Fasting Schedule For Better Physique — A Look At Belly Fat Reduction
Selecting the right intermittent fasting approach requires careful consideration of multiple factors. Your choice should be aligned with your health status, lifestyle demands, and personal goals.
Assess Your Current Eating Patterns
Your existing diet significantly influences which intermittent fasting method you should choose. If you currently follow a diet that is higher in refined carbohydrates and sugars, start with shorter fasting periods. Your body is heavily reliant on glucose for energy, and intermittent fasting results in transitioning to fat burning and may prove challenging initially if your body is accustomed to a frequent steady glucose supply (8).
Those following ketogenic or lower-carbohydrate diets often adapt more easily to longer fasting periods. When your body already efficiently burns fat for fuel, extending fasting windows becomes more manageable, as the body can more efficiently break down fat as a fuel source.
Consider Your Health Status
Certain medical conditions require special consideration before you start intermittent fasting. Individuals with diabetes should work closely with healthcare providers, as fasting can significantly impact blood sugar levels and medication timing (9).
Pregnant and breastfeeding women should avoid intermittent fasting, as should individuals with a history of eating disorders (9). Those taking medications that require food consumption need to coordinate their fasting schedule with their medication regimen. Fasting is also not well-suited for individuals who are looking to gain strength or maintain significant muscle mass.
Evaluate Your Lifestyle Demands
Your daily schedule plays a crucial role in determining feasibility. If you work night shifts, your eating window should align with your sleep-wake cycle rather than following conventional meal times.
Social and family obligations also matter. If family dinners are important cultural or bonding experiences, choose a method that doesn’t interfere with these gatherings. The 16:8 method often works well as it can accommodate either early or late eating windows.
Start Small and Build Gradually
Start with the most manageable approach and gradually extend fasting periods if desired. Someone who is new to intermittent fasting might start with a 12:12 schedule, then progress to 14:10, and eventually reach 16:8 if it feels comfortable.
This gradual approach allows your body to adapt metabolically and more efficiently break down more complex molecules for energy, while you develop sustainable habits. Rushing into extended fasting periods often leads to failure with adherence and potential health complications.
Match Methods to Goals
Different intermittent fasting approaches may better suit specific objectives. For weight loss, the 16:8 method often provides a good balance of effectiveness and sustainability. The 5:2 approach may appeal to those who prefer to maintain normal daily eating patterns most of the time.
For metabolic health benefits, consistency matters more than the specific method chosen. A moderate approach practiced consistently will likely yield better results than an aggressive approach that is followed sporadically.
Women may want to explore our detailed guide on benefits of intermittent fasting for women to understand gender-specific considerations and adaptations.
Food quality remains important during eating windows. While intermittent fasting doesn’t restrict specific foods, making nutritious choices supports your health goals and makes fasting periods more comfortable (10).
Adequate protein intake becomes even more important during intermittent fasting. Protein helps maintain muscle mass during weight loss and promotes satiety, which makes fasting periods easier to manage (11).
High-quality protein sources include:
Maximize nutrition during eating windows by choosing foods that are rich in vitamins, minerals, and beneficial compounds. A balanced diet provides sustained energy and supports overall health (12).
Excellent choices include:
Healthy fats support hormone production, nutrient absorption, and satiety. They’re particularly important as they help stabilize blood sugar and provide sustained energy (13).
Beneficial fat sources include:
Proper hydration supports all bodily functions, together with a sense of fullness (14). Water should be your primary beverage, but you can also enjoy:
While intermittent fasting doesn’t strictly prohibit any foods, certain choices can undermine your goals and make fasting periods more difficult.
1. Highly Processed Foods
Ultra-processed foods often provide empty calories and can trigger cravings that make fasting challenging. These foods typically lack the nutrients your body needs and sweeter options may cause energy crashes, as they will often cause a rapid rise and subsequent fall in blood sugar (15).
You should consider limiting:
The BetterMe: Health Coaching app will provide you with a host of fat-frying fitness routines that’ll scare the extra pounds away and turn your body into a masterpiece! Get your life moving in the right direction with BetterMe!
2. High-Sugar Foods and Beverages
Foods that are high in added sugars can cause rapid blood sugar spikes and crashes, potentially increasing hunger during fasting periods. This includes obvious sources such as candy and soda, but also hidden sugars in seemingly healthy foods (16).
Foods to approach with caution include:
3. Refined Carbohydrates
Highly refined carbohydrates digest quickly and may leave you feeling hungry sooner (17). While they’re not strictly forbidden, these foods may make your eating windows less satisfying and fasting periods more challenging. Although they don’t produce as sharp a rise and fall in blood sugar as high-sugar foods and beverages, they’re not far behind.
Consider moderating:
Pay attention to foods that personally trigger overeating or cravings. These vary by individual but commonly include highly palatable combinations of sugar, fat, and salt. Avoiding personal trigger foods during eating windows can help maintain better control over portion sizes and hunger signals.
Read more: Intermittent Fasting For Belly Fat: 5 Tips You Haven’t Tried
The first week of intermittent fasting typically brings both positive adaptations and temporary challenges as your body adjusts to the new eating pattern.
Many people report improved energy levels after the initial adjustment period. Once your body adapts to using stored fat for fuel and can break this complex molecule down more efficiently, you may experience more stable energy throughout the day rather than the peaks and valleys that are associated with frequent eating.
Mental clarity also often improves. Some individuals find their focus sharpens during fasting periods, possibly due to stabilized blood sugar levels and the metabolic shift to ketone production.
Your hunger signals may become more regulated. Instead of experiencing constant or unpredictable hunger, you may notice clearer distinctions between true hunger and habitual eating urges.
Sleep quality could improve for some individuals, particularly if their previous eating patterns included late-night snacking or large evening meals that interfered with rest.
Initial weight loss commonly occurs within the first week, although this primarily reflects water weight loss, as the supplies of glycogen, or stored carbohydrate, in the muscles decrease, and reduced food volume, rather than significant fat loss. This early change can motivate you to continue.
The initial week may also bring some temporary discomfort as your body adapts. Hunger pangs are common, particularly around your usual meal times. These typically decrease as a shift in eating schedule impacts hunger hormones.
Some people experience mild headaches, particularly if they’re reducing caffeine intake as well or if they’re not staying adequately hydrated during fasting periods.
Energy fluctuations are normal during the adaptation phase. You may feel tired or sluggish as your body learns to efficiently access stored energy during fasting periods.
Mood changes can occur as blood sugar patterns shift. Some individuals report irritability or mood swings during the first few days, although these typically resolve as adaptation occurs.
Social challenges could arise as you navigate meal timing changes. Family dinners or social eating situations may require planning and communication.
By the end of the first week, your body starts to develop more efficient fat-burning pathways. This metabolic flexibility – the ability to switch between glucose and fat for fuel – represents one of the key benefits of intermittent fasting.
Your digestive system may also start to adapt to the concentrated eating periods, potentially leading to improved digestion and reduced bloating for some individuals.
Weight loss with intermittent fasting varies significantly based on individual factors, starting weight, adherence to the chosen method, and overall caloric intake during eating windows.
A sustainable rate of weight loss, which is unlikely to produce a significant drop in metabolism that primes the body to regain weight, ranges from 1-2 pounds per week, which translates to 4-8 pounds per month (18). This range allows for fat loss while preserving muscle mass and metabolic function.
Initial weight loss may appear more dramatic due to water weight reduction. When you reduce your carbohydrate intake or eating frequency, your body releases stored glycogen along with water, which creates rapid initial weight loss that isn’t necessarily fat loss (19).
Starting body weight significantly impacts the rate of loss. Individuals with more weight to lose often experience faster initial results, while those who are closer to their target weight may see more gradual changes.
The specific intermittent fasting method chosen affects results. More restrictive approaches such as alternate day fasting might produce faster weight loss than gentler methods like 16:8, but sustainability often suffers with overly aggressive approaches.
Food choices during eating windows remain important. Consuming excess calories, even within a restricted timeframe, can prevent weight loss entirely. The quality of food choices also impacts satiety, energy levels, and overall success (10).
Some individuals may lose weight more quickly due to factors such as:
Others may experience slower progress due to:
Weight loss involves more than just pounds lost. Body composition changes, including fat loss and potential muscle preservation, matter more for health and appearance than total weight alone.
Intermittent fasting results in improvements in energy levels, blood sugar control, and reduces inflammation that extend beyond weight changes (20). These benefits often prove more valuable in the long term than the numbers on the scale.
Measurements, photos, strength metrics, and fit of clothes often provide better progress indicators than weight alone, particularly as your body composition shifts to emphasize muscle mass over fat mass.
For comprehensive guidance on implementing intermittent fasting effectively, an intermittent fasting guide can provide additional strategies for optimizing your approach.
Yes, sleeping absolutely counts as fasting time. Sleep represents a natural fasting state where your body isn’t receiving food and must rely on stored energy sources. This is actually where the word “breakfast” originates – you’re literally breaking the fast from your overnight sleep period. Most intermittent fasting methods incorporate sleep time into the fasting window, which makes longer fasting periods much more manageable. For example, in a 16:8 protocol, you may fast from 8 pm to 12 pm the next day, with roughly 8 hours of the fasting period occurring during sleep. The “best” meal to skip depends entirely on your lifestyle, preferences, and social obligations. Many people find skipping breakfast most convenient as it allows them to maintain normal lunch and dinner routines with family or colleagues, and certain hormones released overnight, particularly ketones, can already suppress appetite at this time. However, some individuals prefer skipping dinner, particularly if they experience better sleep quality when not eating close to bedtime. Others may choose to skip lunch if their work schedule makes this most practical. Consider your natural hunger patterns, social commitments, and energy needs when deciding which meal to eliminate. The most sustainable choice is the one that fits seamlessly into your existing lifestyle. During your eating window, bananas are perfectly acceptable and can be a nutritious choice. They provide potassium, vitamin B6, vitamin C, and fiber (21). However, during your fasting period, eating a banana would break your fast as it contains calories and natural sugars. If you’re looking for something to help with hunger or energy during fasting periods, stick to zero-calorie options such as water, black coffee, or plain tea. Save nutrient-dense foods such as bananas for your designated eating times. The optimal fasting hours should be aligned with your natural circadian rhythms, lifestyle demands, and personal preferences. Many people find success with a 12 pm to 8 pm eating window (16:8 method), which allows for lunch, an afternoon snack if needed, and dinner while skipping breakfast. Others prefer an earlier eating window, such as 8 am to 4 pm, particularly if they experience better sleep when they don’t eat in the evenings. Night shift workers must adjust their eating windows to align with their unique sleep-wake cycles. The key is consistency – choose hours you can maintain regularly rather than constantly changing your eating window. Your body adapts to predictable patterns more effectively than irregular schedules.Frequently Asked Questions
Does sleeping count as fasting?
Which meal is best to skip for intermittent fasting?
Can I eat a banana during intermittent fasting?
What are the best hours for intermittent fasting?
Intermittent fasting provides a flexible approach to eating that can support various health goals, from weight management to improved metabolic health. The key to success lies in choosing an approach you can fit sustainably into your life.
Remember that intermittent fasting is a tool, not a magic solution. Your overall food choices, sleep quality, stress management, and physical activity all continue to play important roles in your health outcomes. Use intermittent fasting as part of a comprehensive wellness approach rather than a standalone intervention.
Start conservatively, listen to your body, and adjust your approach as necessary. What works for others may not work for you, and that’s perfectly normal. The best intermittent fasting plan is one you can maintain consistently while feeling energized, satisfied, and healthy.
If you have underlying health conditions, are taking medication, or have concerns about whether intermittent fasting is appropriate for your situation, consult a qualified healthcare provider before you start any fasting protocol. Your health and well-being should always take priority over any eating pattern or weight loss goal.
This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not serve to address individual circumstances. It is not a substitute for professional advice or help and should not be relied on for making any kind of decision-making. Any action taken as a direct or indirect result of the information in this article is entirely at your own risk and is your sole responsibility.
BetterMe, its content staff, and its medical advisors accept no responsibility for inaccuracies, errors, misstatements, inconsistencies, or omissions and specifically disclaim any liability, loss or risk, personal, professional or otherwise, which may be incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, of the use and/or application of any content.
You should always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or your specific situation. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking it because of BetterMe content. If you suspect or think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor.